Analytics on Missa

With your consent, we measure which pages and calls people use, so we can improve Missa. We don’t sell data or show ads. Privacy notice

Skip to content
Beta

The best literary magazines to submit to, by tier

Find the best literary magazines to submit to for poetry, fiction and essays, and see how tiers, rankings and pay can shape your list.

Adedayo AgarauFounder, Missa
  • Published
  • 8 min read

Short answer

The best literary magazines to submit to are the ones whose taste, form and terms fit your finished work. Use tiers to organize your ambition, not as a universal quality score. Compare prize recognition, readership, pay and how you submit, then build a short list of well-known journals and smaller magazines you’d actually read.

  • Read a ranking’s method first: Garstang counts Pushcart honors, Missa scores six measures.
  • Match form and length before reputation: Brevity takes 750 words or fewer, One Story 3,000–8,000.
  • Poetry lists US$500 per text poem, One Story US$500 per story, Brevity a US$45 honorarium.

What “top tier” means for a literary magazine

“Top tier” usually means a mix of prize recognition, readership, pay and editorial history. Each one measures something different, and none of them makes one magazine the best home for every manuscript.

Prize anthologies show which published pieces other editors picked. Contributor pay tells you about the terms writers get. Readership is about who might come across your work.

Decide which measure matters to you first. If you want readers of short literary fiction, a magazine that mostly publishes that form can suit you better than a bigger name.

Tiers help when they show you the trade-offs, and they mislead when they hide them under one label. A journal can pay well and reply slowly, publish excellent work to a small readership, or be exactly right for one community.

How literary magazine rankings work

There’s no official literary magazine tier list. Each ranking follows its own method or one editor’s judgment, so read its criteria before you use its order to choose where to submit.

Clifford Garstang’s 2026 overview ranks magazines by ten years of Pushcart Prizes and Special Mentions, and gives recent ones more weight. It doesn’t count submission fees, contributor pay or response time, and it leaves out commercial magazines such as The New Yorker and Harper’s. Garstang’s list is a good measure of one kind of recognition. Its top journal isn’t necessarily the cheapest, the easiest to reach or the right place for your story.

Missa’s ranking method scores each magazine out of 100 across six measures: honors, pay, reply time, fees, submission policy, and archive and ethics. Honors, mainly Pushcart recognition, carry the most weight, at up to 40 points. A fact nobody has recorded earns half its points, so check the record behind any score. The score places each magazine in one of four tiers.

Missa tierScoreHow to use it
Tier 175 and aboveCheck the evidence behind a high score
Tier 260–74.9Compare fit and terms within the group
Tier 345–59.9Look past the label to the work
Tier 4Below 45See which facts are missing before you judge

Check each magazine’s tier and score in the full magazine rankings. Missa’s magazine score leaves out acceptance rates. Our acceptance-rate guide explains what a low rate can and can’t tell you.

Literary magazines to read first

Start with a few magazines that suit your work, and read them before you add more. We grouped the eleven below by what you might want from a submission, not by quality. Use the groups as a guide, not a ranking.

Reading routeMagazineWhy it’s on the listAsk before you send
Widely recognizedThe New YorkerRead the fiction or poetry it actually runsIs your genre’s route open? Fiction’s route is changing in 2026
Widely recognizedThe Paris ReviewProse and poetry, with a route for unsolicited workWhich online month applies, and is the cap reached?
Widely recognizedPoetryPoetry only; free to submit, with published pay ratesIs it open, and can you wait as long as it says?
Long-standing journalsPloughsharesFiction, poetry and nonfiction, each with its own termsAre you sending to the journal or its separate contest?
Long-standing journalsThe Kenyon ReviewSeveral forms; no general reading fee statedWhen’s the next window? September 2026’s has closed
Long-standing journalsAGNIPoetry, prose and hybrid work; explains how it readsDoes the work fit, and which route will you use?
Form or mission firstOne StoryBuilt around the standalone literary short storyIs it 3,000–8,000 words, and is it reading now?
Form or mission firstBrevityEssays of 750 words or fewerIs it a complete short essay, not an excerpt?
Form or mission firstA Public SpaceSeveral genres, and work that crosses themWhich current call fits your form?
Form or mission firstThe CommonWork with a strong sense of placeIs place essential to the piece? Which category?
Form or mission firstThe SunPersonal essays, fiction, poetry and photographyGeneral rules, or the separate Readers Write rules?

Pick a few magazines from the table and read their current work. Send your piece where you can say why it belongs.

The best literary magazines for poetry, fiction and essays

The best magazine for your poem, story or essay publishes the form and length you’ve written. Match those first, then weigh reputation.

Poetry magazines

Start with magazines whose recent poems sit close to what you write. Poetry, The Paris Review, Ploughshares, The Kenyon Review and AGNI each have their own taste, so read several poems from a recent issue before you decide.

Notice range, length, how the poems use the page and how a group of poems hangs together. Send a coherent set of your strongest eligible poems, and don’t pad a packet with weaker work to reach the maximum.

Practical details shape your schedule as much as reputation does. The Poetry submission page says submitting is free and lists current pay rates. The Paris Review guidelines set separate online months for poetry and take postal submissions all year.

Browse poetry calls to find more places to send. Magazines, contests, residencies and grants all turn up there.

Fiction magazines

Match the story’s length and form before you rank anything by reputation. One Story asks for literary stories of 3,000 to 8,000 words, so a flash piece isn’t a fit for its general submissions, however good it is.

For broader literary fiction, read The Paris Review, Ploughshares, AGNI, The Kenyon Review and A Public Space, then find the real matches. Check whether they take excerpts, translations or work with genre elements, and go by the magazine’s own wording, not a directory label.

Routes change, so check each magazine’s route right before you send. The New Yorker’s contact page says its fiction email route closed in August 2026 and that fiction reopens through Submittable on November 1, 2026. An older article telling you to email your story is out of date.

Search fiction calls for what’s open now, and keep a note of places to revisit when their next window opens.

Essay magazines

Know what kind of essay you have before you choose: personal, flash, criticism, a dispatch or reported work. Then look for the magazines that publish that kind.

Brevity takes essays of 750 words or fewer. The Sun publishes personal essays alongside other forms. The Common cares about place and has separate guidance for dispatches. A Public Space welcomes essays and work that doesn’t fit a genre label.

Read the right section. A review, interview or editorial essay in an issue doesn’t mean the magazine takes unsolicited work in that form. Some sections need a pitch, and editors commission others.

Check whether the piece has been online before. Some guidelines count a post on a personal website or social account as already published, whether or not anyone paid you for it.

Use creative nonfiction calls to widen the search, then narrow by form and length. One clear match beats a long list of magazines that publish “nonfiction” in some form.

Literary magazines that pay writers

Several well-known magazines publish their rates. Poetry lists US$500 per text poem from its March 2026 issue, One Story lists US$500 per accepted story, and Brevity lists a US$45 honorarium for featured essays. Make sure the rate covers your category before you count on it.

Paying and charging are separate questions. A paying magazine may still charge a submission fee, and a free one may still pay. Read our guide to submission fees and tip jars before you spend money.

Read the contract before you accept: rights, exclusivity, when you’re paid and contributor copies. A high ranking doesn’t settle whether those terms work for you. If something’s unclear, ask the editor before you agree.

Submitting to newer online literary magazines

A newer magazine is worth your submission when the work it publishes and its terms meet your standards. It may have little prize history and too few tracker reports for useful statistics. A short record is a reason to look closely, not to rule it out.

Read what a newer magazine has published, find out who the editors are and check that its submission terms are clear. Look at how it presents contributors, whether back issues stay online and how it explains rights and fees.

A smaller online magazine can be a strong choice when you want to reach a particular community or try a form. Print isn’t a stand-in for quality. A stable online archive, careful editing and readers who care about your work can matter more than a printed contributor copy.

How to order your submissions across tiers

Order your list by fit, the practical rules and your goals, and treat reputation as one factor among them. A good shortlist has some ambitious picks, some long-standing journals that fit well and some smaller magazines you value. The groups don’t need to be the same size, but keep the list small enough that you can track every reading period and withdrawal rule.

If several good matches allow simultaneous submissions, send to a first group at once instead of waiting on each in turn. Check each policy, log every destination and withdraw quickly if another magazine takes the piece.

If a magazine wants exclusive consideration, decide whether the wait is worth it. You might keep one piece for that magazine and send other work where simultaneous submissions are fine. Don’t break an exclusivity rule to speed things up.

Look at the list again as decisions arrive. A rejection on its own isn’t an instruction to revise, and a personal note isn’t a contract. Revise when you have a clear editorial reason, and keep track of which version each magazine has.

Save the calls on your shortlist, and Missa reminds you before each confirmed deadline.

Magazines open for submissions now

Questions people ask

Check the fee and deadline on the organizer’s page before you pay or apply.

Tell us if anything in this guide has changed.

More guides for artists and writers

Find the call. Make the deadline.

Save calls and get reminders.