How we rank literary magazines and residencies
Check the sources behind every score.
Why we rank literary magazines
The Missa Literary Magazine Index shows which magazines win honors and how each one treats writers. Use it to choose where to send your next story or poems.
Every number comes from a source you can check yourself. When no source records a fact, we say so.
How we score literary magazines
We score every magazine out of 100 on six measures.
- Honors, up to 40 points. We count a magazine’s Pushcart Prize recognition over the past ten years, and recent years count more. The most honored magazine in each index earns the full 40. Others earn less on a square-root curve, so even one honor counts. Every piece in Best Small Fictions adds 2.5 points and every piece in Best Microfiction adds 2, or half that after five years. Together they add at most 10 points, in fiction and in the overall index.
- Pay, up to 15 points. A magazine earns full points by paying 5¢ a word, $50 a poem or $100 a piece. Smaller payments earn less. Contributor copies earn two points, and unpaid work earns none.
- Reply time, up to 15 points. A reply within a month earns full points. Points fall as the wait grows, to none after a year.
- Fees, up to 15 points. A magazine that’s free to submit to earns full points, and fewer as its reading fee rises. Waiving the fee for some writers still earns most of the points.
- Submission policy, up to 10 points. Magazines earn points for accepting simultaneous submissions and for letting you check on your work within six months.
- Archive and ethics, up to 5 points. Magazines earn points for keeping their archive online, reading submissions blind and publishing first-time writers.
When a fact isn’t on record
- We never guess. When no source records a fact, you’ll see “Not recorded”.
- A missing fact earns half its points, so a gap doesn’t lift a magazine or hold it back. One exception: a magazine that doesn’t say when you can check on your work earns 2.5 of the 4 points for checking in.
- A partial answer, like “pays in cash” with no amount, earns the middle of what that answer could score.
- Each magazine’s page shows which facts we have on record, so you can see how much of its score rests on them.
Where the facts come from
- Pushcart Prize recognition, 2024 to 2026, from Clifford Garstang’s yearly tally at cliffordgarstang.com.
- The flash anthologies: the published contents of Best Microfiction (2019 to 2026) and Best Small Fictions (2023 to 2025).
- The magazines’ own submission pages for what they charge, and for pay and reply time when no listing has them. We checked each fact word for word against the magazine’s page. We leave out prizes, paid fast-track reading and art calls. We use the fee for the cheapest way any writer can send work.
- Public magazine listings for pay, reply time and submission policy. Each listing counts from the year of its last update.
- Writers’ own reports. A magazine with 5 or more reports gets its recorded reply time from them. We keep reports without names or accounts.
The index checks its sources every month and begins a new year each January. It last checked them on 3 November 2026.
Tiers
The total score places each magazine in one of four tiers.
- Tier 1Score 75 and above
- Tier 2Score 60 to 74.9
- Tier 3Score 45 to 59.9
- Tier 4Score below 45
A tier is a summary, not a verdict. A magazine with few facts on record can sit lower than its reputation, because the index won’t assume what it can’t confirm.
Four indexes
The 2026 index ranks 550 magazines overall, 309 in fiction, 288 in poetry and 162 in nonfiction. A magazine joins a genre’s index once it has an honor in that genre.
What the numbers show
- The ten most honored magazines hold 21% of all Pushcart recognition in the index, and the fifty most honored hold 56%.
- 208 of the 496 magazines in the Pushcart tally score one point or less.
The fee, pay and reply figures count only the magazines with that fact on record.
- 68% of the fifty most honored magazines charge a reading fee, against 45% of the rest. The typical fee we know of is $3.
- 83% of the fifty most honored magazines pay contributors in cash, against 51% of the rest.
- 19% of the fifty most honored magazines take more than six months to reply, against 12% of the rest.
- 120 magazines have placed work in Best Microfiction or Best Small Fictions since 2022, and 38 of them also appear in the Pushcart record.
- 45 magazines in the Pushcart record have closed, and 34 are paused or quiet. We keep their record in the index.
- of Pushcart recognition goes to the ten most honored magazines
- 21%
- of Pushcart recognition goes to the ten most honored magazines
- of Pushcart recognition goes to the fifty most honored
- 56%
- of Pushcart recognition goes to the fifty most honored
- of 496 magazines in the Pushcart tally score one point or less
- 208
- of 496 magazines in the Pushcart tally score one point or less
How we score artist residencies
We score each residency from two public residency directories, residents’ reviews and the open calls on Missa. Every fact links to the page it came from.
- Funding, up to 35 points. A program earns 25 for charging no residency fee and 10 more for paying artists a stipend.
- What residents say, up to 30 points. We average past residents’ ratings, then count in five middle ratings of 3 out of 5. That way one glowing review can’t carry a program on its own.
- Room to work, up to 20 points. A program earns 10 for providing all meals (7 for some) and 10 for a private studio.
- Standing and access, up to 15 points. A program earns up to 5 for its years running, 5 when both directories list it (2.5 for one) and 5 for an open call taking applications now.
A fact no source records gets half its points, so we never reward or punish a program for what we haven’t found. Open a program’s details to see which facts are on record.
How to use the rankings to choose where to submit
- Mix where you send each piece: a few long shots, several good fits and a magazine or two you already love.
- Sending one piece to several places at once? Turn on “Simultaneous OK” and “Replies within 3 months”.
- Use the “No fee” filter to see only the magazines we know you can submit to for free.